Will I write a letter of
recommendation for you?
Yes. However, please read the following and choose the set of
instructions that apply to you:
First, you need to keep in mind that everyone applying to graduate
school is at the top of the distribution. It's not a numbers game,
it's
a question of fit. You need to make yourself stand out by crafting a
narrative that describes you, your skills and abilities, and your
goals. Instead of asking why you need a graduate program to accept
you,
ask why a graduate program needs someone like you. Answer that
question
for them. The most important step there is choosing wisely. Choose
programs that you qualify for and where you will fit in. If your
reach
never exceeds your grasp, reach farther. But, be reasonable.
Letters are an important part of your personal narrative. Choose
people
to write letters for you who will help to complete the picture of
who
you are and what you can do. Be strategic. If, after due reflection,
you feel that I can be one of the people who writes for you, go on
to
the next step.
Two more things to consider:
1. Steve Jobs said this better than anyone I've ever heard say it.
Read
this, and take a lot of time to reflect on it as you plan for
graduate
school or your next step:
“No one wants to die. Even people who want to go to heaven don’t
want
to die to get there. And yet death is the destination we all
share. No
one has ever escaped it. And that is as it should be, because
Death is
very likely the single best invention of life. It is life’s change
agent. It clears out the old to make way for the new. Right now
the new
is you, but someday not too long from now, you will gradually
become
the old and be cleared away. Sorry to be so dramatic, but it is
quite
true.
"Your time is limited, so don’t waste it living someone else’s
life.
Don’t be trapped by dogma—which is living with the results of
other
people’s thinking. Don’t let the noise of others’ opinions drown
out
your own inner voice. And most important, have the courage to
follow
your heart and intuition. They somehow already know what you truly
want
to become. Everything else is secondary.”
2. This article has some helpful advice on what not to do in your
application. There are also a lot of sources with advice on what to
do.
Track those down, read them, apply what you learn.
Appleby, D. C., & Appleby, K. M.
(2006). Kisses of death in the graduate school application
process.
Teaching of
Psychology, 33, 19-24.
doi:
10.1207/s15328023top3301_5
How to ask me for a letter:
NOTE: Include your personal pronouns for any option below. I'll
need that for the letter.
1. I know you well, we've done research together, we've discussed
your
career goals and personal statement, etc.
What are you doing here? Just ask me, these letters are easy.
2. You had me for research methods
and
you completed an independent project.
I can write you a letter. We have been through an experience
together
that allows me to fill in blanks like "works well with others," "is
responsible," "can work with little supervision." I would describe
this
letter as your "second" letter. I know more about you in more
contexts
than your average professor who just had you for one class. But, I'm
not that person you worked with on research or an internship for an
entire semester.
I need to know from you:
- What are you applying for?
- What kinds of things are they looking for in you (so I can
make
sure
to mention as many of them as I should know something about)?
- What makes you special and what of that would you like me to
try
to work in to my letter?
- Are we trying to mesh my letter with your personal statement?
If
so,
send it to me and tell me how my letter fits into your
evaluation of
yourself and your academic career.
- Are there liabilities in your record? Should I know about them
based
on our relationship? Would it help for me to address those in my
letter? (E.g., did you party too much as a freshman and wreck
your GPA,
but you've done great since then?)
- What was your independent project, what did you find, etc.
What
particular challenges did you face during the project, how did
you deal
with those?
If there are special circumstances (e.g., you presented at MTPA),
list
those for me. If we had more than just research methods together,
list
the rest of the classes and the semesters.
Email the information, we can meet if you'd like.
3. You had me in a class, you did
well, and you think I could write a positive letter.
I can write you a letter. I will have your grades and any papers or
work submitted electronically. The letter will be positive. However,
in
the ranking of
letters, it will be relatively weak. We had one class a while back,
so
that will limit what I can say. If you are being strategic and you
have
that killer letter from someone who knows you well and has worked
with
you outside of a class context (e.g., research, internship), mine
will
be a strong compelement to back up the "she is academically well
prepared" leg of your table.
That leaves me with two questions:
a. Do you have that killer letter, or, what are you doing to get it?
b. Is what you need from me consistent with what I can say (further
proof that you are acdemically well qualified)? If so, I could use a
little more information:
- What are you applying for?
- What kinds of things are they looking for in you (so I can
make
sure
to mention as many of them as I should know something about)?
- What, specifically, made you choose me to write a letter?
- What makes you special and what of that would you like me to
try
to work in to my letter?
- Are we trying to mesh my letter with your personal statement?
If
so,
send it to me and tell me how my letter fits into your
evaluation of
yourself and your academic career.
- Are there liabilities in your record? Should I know about them
based
on our relationship? Would it help for me to address those in my
letter? (E.g., did you party too much as a freshman and wreck
your GPA,
but you've done great since then?)
Remind me of how I know you. List every class that we had together
and
the semester of each class.
Email the information, we can meet if you'd like.